Skip to content
Share:

What's Your Best Savings Option? It Depends

Published: July 21, 2017

There's no question that saving is a wise plan, but where to put your savings isn't always so cut and dried. Does a regular savings account fit your needs best, or would a money market account be a smarter choice? And what about saving certificates? Which option is right for you depends largely on the amount you're saving and your cash-flow situation.

Savings Accounts

The basic savings account is popular for its safety and accessibility. These accounts are federally insured up to certain limits, with steady returns that compound regularly, and the minimum balance required to avoid a fee is usually low.

Although there may be a limit to the number of free monthly transactions, customers can make withdrawals as desired without penalty. Savings accounts have come a long way since the days of passbooks and paper statements; depositors now may enjoy ATM, telephone and remote account access. The downside is that annual percentage yields, or APYs, on savings accounts tend to be lower than the rates of return for other types of investments.

Money Market Accounts

Another safe, federally insured option is a money market account (not to be confused with a money market fund, which is a mutual fund). As with savings accounts, returns compound regularly; online, remote and ATM banking is available, and there are no maturity terms to contend with.

Money market accounts typically offer higher returns than savings accounts at traditional banks and credit unions that provide in-person services, allowing your money to grow at a faster rate. Some money market accounts also come with the added benefit of limited check-writing capability.

Money market accounts do come with a few considerations, however. The average required minimum balance to avoid fees tends to be significantly higher than for savings accounts. And in some cases, these accounts may allow for fewer of certain types of transactions per month.

Share Certificates

If you're in a position to leave money in place for a longer period — in exchange for a higher return — consider investing in saving certificates. With share certificates offered by credit unions and certificates of deposit from banks, you agree not to touch the money you put in for a fixed period of time, which can run from a few weeks to five years or more. In return, you receive a greater return at the end of the term than if you'd put the cash in a money market or traditional savings account. Impatience will cost you, though: If you decide to withdraw your money before the end of the term, you'll generally get hit with early withdrawal penalties.

The Bottom Line

When comparing these saving options, there isn't a single clear winner. The choice comes down to how much money you want to put in a savings plan, what kind of access you need to have to it and how long you can comfortably let it sit and increase in value. Taking the time to compare rates, minimum balances and fees will help you find the best savings vehicle for your personal situation.

© Copyright 2016 NerdWallet, Inc. All Rights Reserved

View all posts

Members' Voice Testimonials

This credit union is the best, I love the customer service and you can't beat the interest rates. I'm happy to be a member of this great credit union.

The branch manager introduced herself and was extremely helpful. She stated that if there is anything we ever need to please let her know. Very positive experience!

Greta was absolutely amazing - as always. She makes me and my parents feel valued and supported. We are forever grateful. [The Credit Union] has been hugely supportive over many years. And we feel known and cared for.

Long as I have been with the credit union, I haven't had any problems. I also like the protection on my account.

My overall experience at the credit union was exceptional. The staff was hospitable offering water, my service was timely and professional and the office was well lit and clean.

As a member for more than 40 years, i have always had great service from the USSFCU and know that they stand behind their great reputation.

A top rate Credit Union, [I'm] privileged to be part of! Thank you for all you do for our family! USSFCU Credit Union was able to resolve our financial situation - vehicle, personal loans, customer service/recommendations, within 6 months. We belonged to another credit union for over 20 years, with results not even close to comparison. We switched ...

Your people and products are amazing. The recent [online banking] overhaul is phenomenal. [I've] been electronic banking since Tele action phone banking - paying bills with my push button landline decades ago. USSFCU is light years ahead of everyone else in terms of ease of use and client experience!

I have been a member for more than 30 years. I no longer reside in the DC area but continue to bank with USSFCU because of the ease and the customer service.

I have been a member for over 50 years, and I have always gotten good service with loans, when I had to have service at a branch, and when I needed to have money sent to me from my savings account. The personnel have always been friendly and treated me with respect.

I especially appreciate being able to quickly speak with someone (not a robot) and that person has always been knowledgeable and helpful.

Excellent customer service streamlined and transparent process. The representatives are efficient, knowledgeable, and understanding of the type of loans offered by Credit Union.

The USSFCU behaves as a credit union ought to behave. The staff works with and for the members, not for a corporate board. Interest rates for a car loan, a home improvement loan, and a mortgage are low and terms are transparent.

Staff are courteous and friendly to work with. Very knowledgeable about services and products offered or available. Excellent follow-up with customers.

I have appreciated USSFCU services for many years since I left my work on Capitol Hill. I have appreciated the occasional webinars on purchasing a home or retirement planning.

I have been a member since 2006, and have always appreciated the customer service response to any concern or query. In addition, as I have traveled extensively, USSFCU has provided support and access.

I've had a credit union account for decades, even though I no longer work on Capitol Hill. I now have two accounts. I've been able to do all of our banking remotely, by app or by phone.

I have been a USSFCU member for almost 20 years. There is nowhere else I want my money to be. I always receive excellent service.

I deeply appreciate the stellar service, the proficiency, the professionalism, and the kindness. I am truly honored and grateful to bank with a financial institution that treats customers like family.

Read More testimonials.